3 Years After Their Deaths, Someone Is Still Paying These Homeowners’ Bills

When relatives in Michigan unlocked the door to their late parents’ home three years after the couple’s deaths, they expected dust, debt, and silence. Instead, they found something stranger: The lights were on and the property taxes were current—even though no one in the family had paid a dime.

The story, shared in a Reddit thread on r/RealEstateAdvice, sparked dozens of theories. Who would keep paying for a deceased couple’s home? What would they have to gain? But beneath the mystery lies a growing national problem: America’s fragile system for handling estate transfers.

Over the next 25 years, an estimated $124 trillion in wealth—much of it in real estate—will change hands. Yet nearly half of younger Americans say they aren’t prepared to maintain or manage an inherited property.

It’s a gap that could leave family inheritances vulnerable to neglect, bad actors, or opportunists—just like the Michigan family’s experience.

Initially, after evaluating the modular home, the heirs thought it was better left to the bank: The home was run-down, likely underwater, and not worth the cost of repairs. But while they expected foreclosure to take care of it, three years later, the home had never been to auction. So who was keeping it current?

Why the lender doesn’t care who pays

Most people assume they have to pay their mortgage, and in practice, that’s true. But a more accurate way to phrase it might be: Your mortgage has to be paid—by you or anyone else.

“The lender generally does not care who is paying the mortgage. They just care that they are getting paid and that the obligation is current,” explains attorney Steven Rotenberg. “So your mother could pay your (or my) mortgage if she wanted to.”

This extends to other obligations, like property taxes. Third parties are welcome to pay your bills for you, so long as they’re paid.

If, however, your debts are delinquent for a set period of time, the creditor then gains the ability to foreclose on the home. In the case of a delinquent mortgage, the bank would have the authority to foreclose; in the case of property taxes, the county.

They’re small distinctions with consequences when homeowners die. In these cases, the responsibility to keep payments current (mortgage, property tax, utilities) usually falls to their heirs. But if no one notifies the servicer of the death, the account can continue indefinitely, as if nothing happened.

In the Michigan case, that quirk of bureaucracy seems to have delayed foreclosure. But it also raises a far stranger question: If the family wasn’t paying, who was, and why?

The innocent, the opportunist, and the predator

The mystery has an eerie feel, but experts say there are rational explanations for why a deceased homeowner’s mortgage and taxes might stay current.

“What I think may have happened here is that the mortgage was put on autopay with taxes included in the mortgage payments and escrowed with the servicer, who then pays the lender and the taxes,” explains Rotenberg. “The owner died, and autopay continued for some reason.”

In this case, the couple’s bank account may have had enough funds to keep the house solvent for the past three years, allowing it to go on as if nothing had happened. 

However, the heirs originally suspected that the home was already behind on its mortgage payments and expected imminent foreclosure. If this is true, it points to a more deliberate cause.

“A situation in which a third party vows to pay the mortgage and property taxes of a deceased homeowner without the family’s participation is usually indicative of one or a combination of three aggressive economic maneuvers,” says Sain Rhodes, a real estate expert at Clever Offers. 

“A tax lien buyer who intends to foreclose on the home, a title company engaged in a quiet title action against the property’s ownership, or a potential buyer who wants to take possession of it,” she continues.

In each case, outsiders use the appearance of good stewardship to build a legal claim over time.

Fred Loguidice, a real estate investor, agrees: “This covert activity strongly indicates one of two planned moves by a third party, and both are predatory against the heirs,” he warns. “A tax lien investor ... or a quiet title action.”

A tax lien investor pays off back taxes in exchange for the right to charge additional interest to the property owner, and, if not paid, eventually forecloses on the property and takes ownership. It’s a practice that’s been the subject of controversy after a number of states failed to pass laws to protect homeowners from losing all the equity in their homes to these kinds of sales. In these cases, some homeowners lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in equity over tax debts as small as a few thousand dollars.

Michigan is one such state.

“Less than 5% of owners navigate the claim process properly and are able to get payment for the excess value of the property taken from them,” Christina Martin, a lawyer with the Pacific Legal Foundation who is fighting home equity theft, told Realtor.com.

It’s similar to a quiet title action. In Michigan, the owner of a tax deed—a document that transfers ownership of a property to a government in the case of a tax debt—can take possession of the home if the owners or heirs of a home don’t notify the tax deed holder within a set amount of time before foreclosure proceedings.

In both scenarios, time—and silence—are the investor’s greatest allies.

The clock starts the moment someone dies

So what recourse do the heirs have at this point?

“If the family hasn't already done so, they must immediately open a formal probate case and formally record the death certificates,” says Loguidice. “This creates a clear legal claim to the property.”

Until probate is opened, the home exists in limbo, still tied to the deceased owners. That gap gives outside actors room to maneuver, whether it’s a tax lien buyer paying the bills to gain leverage or a title claimant assembling evidence of ownership.

Rhodes also recommends a title search.

“Perform a title search to determine if there have been liens or claims filed against the property, and then contact both the mortgage servicer and the tax assessor to determine exactly who has been paying,” she adds.

Experts outline a clear sequence for families who discover unexplained payments:

1. Contact the lender to request a complete payment history.
2. Hire a probate or real estate attorney to open the estate and establish standing.
3. Notify the county tax assessor and confirm who has been paying the taxes.
4. Place a fraud-watch alert with the county clerk.

“One can also place fraud watches on one’s property and be notified by the clerk if any changes are made to the title or any encumbrances,” notes Rotenberg.

Once an outsider’s payments or filings appear in county records, undoing them can require months of legal work. And if action isn’t taken fast enough, it may result in the loss of the inheritance.

The silent epidemic of unsettled estates

What happened in Michigan isn’t as rare or strange as it might seem. Across the country, thousands of homes sit in a similar kind of purgatory: owned by no one, maintained by someone, and watched closely by those who understand how to turn a legal gray area into an opportunity.

“We frequently encounter properties where an heir thought they inherited a clean title but are suddenly blindsided by an investor or relative who has been quietly maintaining the property to establish a claim,” says Loguidice. “This happens due to postdeath title transfer gaps.”

Those gaps can stretch for months or even years, especially when heirs live out of state or assume the home’s affairs have already been settled. During that time, mortgages can be on autopay, tax bills can slip through escrow unnoticed, and third parties can insert themselves into the property’s paper trail.

Still, not every case ends in a courtroom.

“Title fraud and equity theft is fairly rare, but it happens,” notes Rotenberg. “I really don’t see much of an opportunity for fraud here because I don’t see how it could convey title to the fraudster.”

Most of the time, these stories resolve benignly: Autopay eventually fails, accounts close, and families regain control. But when they don’t, the results can be devastating: lost equity, drawn-out litigation, and the erasure of an inheritance that once seemed safe.