Nancy Guthrie’s Disappearance Takes New Twist as Former FBI Agent Reveals Contents of 4 Ransom Notes

To see our latest updates on the Nancy Guthrie case, please click here.

A former FBI agent has revealed that she received four disturbing ransom messages concerning the disappearance of Savannah Guthrie's mother, Nancy Guthrie—including an unsettling image that appeared to depict the missing 84-year-old in distress.

The revelation comes more than eight months after Nancy vanished from her Arizona home, with authorities still searching for answers about what happened to the mother of the "Today" show anchor.

Former FBI agent Jennifer Coffindaffer, who now works as a law and justice contributor for NewsNation, has revealed that she was targeted by individuals claiming to have information about Nancy's disappearance, with the senders demanding cryptocurrency in exchange for her return.

However, Coffindaffer has cast doubt on the authenticity of the communications, explaining that she believes the messages were sent by people attempting to capitalize on the high-profile investigation.

The former federal agent received the four emails in April, roughly two months after Nancy was allegedly abducted from her residence in the Catalina Foothills area near Tucson.

Anyone with any information about Nancy Guthrie's case should call 1-800-CALL-FBI, 520-351-4900, or 88-CRIME, or visit tips.fbi.gov.

Rather than engaging with the senders, Coffindaffer passed the communications to the FBI, which informed her that the cryptocurrency wallet address provided did not correspond with those associated with ransom notes investigators considered potentially authentic.

Although she initially decided against discussing the emails publicly, another development in September prompted her to share what had happened.

Coffindaffer learned that Lauren Serpa, a woman who lives near Nancy's home, had received a similar communication.

Serpa subsequently shared details of the message on Facebook, including a photograph that appeared nearly identical to one Coffindaffer had received months earlier.

The similarities left Coffindaffer concerned that other people following the investigation might also be approached by individuals seeking money.

According to NewsNation, Coffindaffer believes she may have been targeted because of the public commentary and advice she has offered about the investigation.

She also expressed concern about how the senders obtained her contact information.

The messages arrived at a personal email address that Coffindaffer said she does not ordinarily share, rather than one of the accounts she regularly uses for professional purposes.

Adding to her suspicions, the communications contained religious references that appeared tailored to her Catholic faith.

Coffindaffer suggested that the level of personalization could indicate a coordinated operation, although investigators have not publicly confirmed that an organized group is responsible.

Perhaps the most unsettling element of the emails was an image that appeared to show Nancy with her hair shaved, dirt covering her face, and a tear beneath one eye.

Coffindaffer believes the photograph was designed to make recipients fear for Nancy's safety and persuade them that sending money could help secure her release.

The former agent said the demands included relatively small amounts of bitcoin compared with the multimillion-dollar sums previously associated with other ransom communications in the case.

However, there is no verified evidence that the individuals who contacted Coffindaffer had any involvement in Nancy's disappearance or possessed genuine information about her whereabouts.

The revelations come shortly after the Pima County Sheriff's Department announced that it was investigating another possible ransom message connected to the case.

On Sept. 29, authorities confirmed that they had received information about a new communication and were examining whether it had any credibility.

The department subsequently determined that the message was not credible and warned the public about potential attempts to exploit the investigation for financial gain.

Meanwhile, Savannah has issued several heartbreaking pleas to her mother's kidnappers, begging them to bring her home.

What is the full timeline of Nancy Guthrie's disappearance?

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos noted during a media briefing on Feb. 5 that, while times are approximate, his team has pieced together several pieces of evidence that indicate Nancy's movements—and the timeline of her apparent abduction.

Nancy was reported missing at around 12 p.m. local time on Feb. 1, around 14 hours after she was dropped off at the property following a family dinner. When she failed to turn up at her usual church gathering on Sunday, her friends alerted her family, who found her home was empty.

SATURDAY, JAN. 31

5:32 p.m. Nancy travels to Annie's house in an Uber for "dinner and playing games with the family."

9:48 p.m. A garage door at Nancy's house opens when she was dropped off at the property by her daughter.

9:50 p.m. The garage door closes, indicating that Nancy was inside the home.

SUNDAY, FEB. 1

1:47 a.m. Nancy's doorbell security camera is disconnected.

2:12 a.m. Movement is detected on a security camera at the home. No footage of this is currently available.

2:28 a.m. Nancy's pacemaker app indicates that the device has been disconnected from her phone.

11:00 a.m. Nancy fails to arrive at the home of a friend, where she had been due to watch a church service livestream.

11:56 a.m. Nancy's family travels to her home to check on her and finds the property empty.

12:03 p.m. The family calls 911 to report Nancy missing.

12:14 p.m. Police officers arrive at Nancy's home.