‘One of the Oldest Homes Still Standing’ in New Jersey’s Warren County Lists for Just $400K

One of New Jersey's most historically significant—and oldest—properties has come onto the market for just under $400,000, complete with a rare opportunity to shepherd it into the modern era in a new and original way.

The dwelling, which has historically been known as Hall House, was built in Warren County in 1750 and still retains much of its original 18th-century character to this day.

Among those features are pine floors, beefed window and wood trims, and hand-hewn framing timbers, all hallmarks of colonial craftsmanship. Two historic fireplaces in the living and dining areas remain intact, though they are recommended for decorative use only.

In short, the home is irreplaceable—and, according to listing agent Maria F. McDonough of Coldwell Banker Realty, impossible to replicate today because of the extraordinary quality of craftsmanship that went into its construction.

"You couldn’t build a home like this today," she told NJ.com. “It’s a beautiful home, with the quality of the workmanship.”

"Historically known as the Hall House and built circa 1750, this property is one of the oldest homes still standing in Warren County," the listing says. "Many of the original interior details remain, including hewn framing timbers, pine floors, chair rails, and beaded window and door trims."

The sentiment highlights not just the age of the house, but also the care and skill involved in its original construction, a level of detail rare in modern buildings.

The home itself offers two bedrooms and one bathroom across two floors, sitting on a 1.59-acre lot and, despite its age, the property has been adapted to modern living while retaining its historic layout.

The first floor includes a living room, dining area, and a kitchen that reflects the home’s colonial roots. A sunroom added around 1983 introduces light and flexible space suitable for a home office, studio, or additional living area.

Upstairs, two bedrooms are accessed via separate staircases, maintaining the house’s historic flow and offering privacy in each space.

While the listing concedes that the main house is in need of "some TLC," it highlights the fact that the property offers many opportunities—both with regard to the primary residence and the other structures on the parcel.

Beyond the main house, the property includes two barns. The smaller barn serves as storage, while the larger barn benefits from CO-1 zoning, allowing for potential occupational or commercial use.

"The main barn can be used for agricultural purposes or converted into occupational or commercial use, while the smaller barn can be used as storage or garage space," the listing notes.

In the past, the larger of those two spaces has been used as the venue for antique auctions, demonstrating the property’s versatility for both personal and professional use.

The home’s combination of historic charm and practical potential makes it especially appealing for buyers interested in both preservation and lifestyle. It is situated in the countryside, backing up to a horse farm, but with huge trees and expansive space that promises privacy—making it the perfect space to live out a cottage-core dream.

It’s also conveniently located on Route 31, meaning it’s less than a 10 minute drive to the local town of Phillipsburg, and only an hour and a half to New York. 

2481 Belvidere Road also reflects a larger story about New Jersey’s historic housing stock. Homes from the 1700s are rare in Warren County, which was established in 1825.

Owning this home offers more than shelter; it provides a connection to the state’s early history and the chance to maintain a tangible piece of the past.

The property’s acreage and outbuildings also supply opportunities for outdoor living, gardening, or small-scale agricultural use. Whether for a family looking for character-filled space or an entrepreneur seeking a historic venue, the site’s versatility is a standout feature.

With a listing price of $400,000, 2481 Belvidere Road represents a rare combination of history, functionality, and potential. Its enduring craftsmanship, preserved details, and flexible layout make it more than a home. It is a living piece of New Jersey heritage, ready for the next chapter of its long story.